DOE's rulings on rehearing of its 202(c) power plant orders have all come after the orders expired
Description and use
DOE’s rehearing decisions for 202(c) power plant orders are issued only after the orders expire, delaying operators’ legal recourse.
Problem
DOE routinely issues rehearing denials and reasoned orders for 202(c) power plant orders only after the orders have expired, delaying legal recourse for plant operators.
Outcome
The analysis shows that DOE’s rehearing decisions for 202(c) orders are consistently delayed until after the orders expire, limiting operators’ ability to seek timely judicial review.
Workflow
- Collect all 34 DOE 202(c) order pages from energy.gov
- Compile requests and DOE replies into a CSV
- Count requests, denials, and reasoned orders
- Analyze timing of rehearing decisions relative to order expiration
- Publish findings and predictions on GitHub
Evidence
DOE issued 24 notices that rehearing was "denied by operation of law", 31 to 46 days after the request, always while the order was still in force.
Only 10 orders got a reasoned order on rehearing, and all 10 came after the challenged order had expired: 18 to 135 days after (median 86).
The latest two, dated 16 October 2026, address the Schahfer and Culley (IN) orders that expired on 21 June.
The D.C. Circuit vacated the first Campbell order on 11 September 2026, 386 days after it expired.
- Record date: 2026-10-19T11:41:10.409Z