I made 4 manga pages with AI. Ranking them worst to best found the variable.

Description and use

The author used Tsubaki.3 to generate four-page manga scenes, encountering character blending and identity issues. Iterative editing revealed two key variables—panel consistency and character identity—that predicted page quality.

Problem

Generating consistent manga pages with an AI model produced varying quality and unintended character changes, requiring multiple editing passes.

Outcome

The workflow revealed that two variables—panel content consistency and character identity preservation—predicted the order of pages from worst to best. Despite achieving a correct layout in the final pass, the model repeatedly altered the main character’s appearance, highlighting a limitation in maintaining continuity across edits.

Workflow

• 1. Split scene into panels and write detailed prompt for each panel.
• 2. Generate initial page with Tsubaki.3.
• 3. Identify failures (extra characters, missing elements).
• 4. Apply targeted edit to remove unwanted figures and correct hands.
• 5. Chain additional edits in PixAI Studio to refine layout and content.
• 6. Evaluate each pass for consistency and correctness.
• 7. Rank pages by required human rework to identify influencing variables.

Evidence

Two failures, both involving the second character.

Source

Across two chained edits, each pass redrew her from the description rather than inheriting the face from the previous step.

Source