Record an OSS Replay Packet Before Model Dissent

说明与用途

OSS 重放包记录失败上下文和补丁，任何审阅者都能在请求模型异议前重现问题并验证修复。

问题

Open‑source fixes fail when review context lives only in a chat window; later readers cannot replay the bug, diff, or prompt.

结果

The workflow produces a reproducible, version‑controlled review packet that allows any reviewer to replay the failure and patch, request only dissent from a model, and score the dissent against a trusted oracle checklist.

工作流

• Pin the upstream commit on a clean worktree
• Capture the failing command and record stdout, stderr, and exit code
• Apply the minimal human patch and generate a patch file
• Write the manifest.json with project, commit, commands, and patch references
• Replay the failure and patch on a clean server, recording pass/fail outputs
• Ask the model only for dissent notes, providing manifest, patch, and oracle checklist
• Score the dissent notes against the oracle checklist to confirm, reject, or flag untested notes

证据

A model review is useful only after a frozen replay packet exists. That packet stores the pinned commit, the failing command, and the patch.

来源

Open-source fixes fail when review context lives only in a chat window. A later reader cannot replay the bug, the diff, or the exact prompt.

来源

The packet stays small enough to copy onto a clean server. It stores inputs, commands, and the expected local result.

来源